Secret Sister Questionnaire

A Secret Sister questionnaire for a church, a women’s group or friends: print the form and a sign-up sheet, or fill it in and send your answers to the organizer by link.

Your answers stay in your browser; a link carries only what you type

Secret Sister form for church and women’s groups: questions, sign-up sheet and reveal ideas

The questions

Fill in your answers, or untick the questions you don’t want on the printed or copied questionnaire.

Write only what you’d want your Secret Sister to read, and send it to the organizer, not the group chat: anyone with the link can open it.

For each participant: your answers

For the organizer: the blank questionnaire

Draw names for your Secret Sisters (no email)

For a PDF, choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

What a Secret Sister program is and how to use this form

Quick answer: in a Secret Sister program, the women of a church or group each fill in a short “about me” form and are matched at random. For a few months or most of a year, each one prays for her sister and encourages her with cards and small gifts, and they meet at a reveal at the end. Every church sets its own rules: one we read asks for three months and says gifts are “not expected or necessary”.

Pick a set for a church or women’s group, a youth group or camp, or friends and coworkers, which leaves out the faith questions. Print blank forms two per page and a numbered sign-up sheet, or let each person fill it in here and send the link to the organizer only. Draw the names with the gift exchange organizer, which gives each person a private link with no emails.

This has nothing to do with the “Secret Sister” gift chain that goes around Facebook. That one asks strangers to mail gifts and recruit friends, and the Better Business Bureau calls it an illegal pyramid scheme. A church program is a closed group of people who know each other, with an organizer, no recruiting and nothing promised in return.

Questions by group

QuestionChurch or women’s groupYouth group or campFriends or coworkers
Where gifts can be left (room, mailbox, front office)YesYesYes
Birthday (month and day)YesYesYes
Another date that matters (anniversary…)Yes——
Favorite color(s)YesYesYes
Flowers or plants: favorites — or none?Yes—Yes
Favorite snacks or treatsYesYesYes
Favorite drink (coffee or tea order?)YesYesYes
Favorite scent (candles, lotion…)Yes—Yes
Hobbies and things you do for funYesYesYes
Books, movies, music or shows you like—Yes—
Sizes (shirt, socks…)——Yes
If someone gives a gift card: which store?——Yes
A favorite Bible verseYesYes—
A favorite hymn or worship songYesYes—
What would you like prayer for?YesYes—
What brightens a hard day—YesYes
Things you’d love to get——Yes
Please, nothing like…YesYesYes
Allergies or foods you avoidYesYesYes

A prayer request is personal. Write only what you’d want your Secret Sister to read, and send your link to the organizer rather than the group chat, because anyone with the link can open it.

How to start a Secret Sister program

  1. Decide how long it runs and how it ends. Three months is an easy first try; most of a year is the classic.
  2. Set the expectations: pray, send a note, and spend what you agreed, if anything.
  3. Announce it and put out the sign-up sheet. Leave it open to newcomers if you can.
  4. Everyone fills in the questionnaire, on paper or here, and gives it to the organizer.
  5. Draw names with the gift exchange organizer, which sends each woman a private link, or match them yourselves in prayer.
  6. Give each woman the form of the sister she drew. The organizer keeps the only full list.
  7. Set up a gift table or use the church office, so gifts and cards can arrive without giving anyone away.
  8. Check in halfway, then hold the reveal.

Secret Sister rules and guidelines

RuleA choice that works
CommitmentSay the end date on the sign-up sheet, and ask people to stay to the end
GiftsSmall and occasional; cards and prayer count just as much
BudgetOne amount for everyone, stated before signing up
Prayer requestsStay between the two sisters and the organizer
SecrecySign cards “Your Secret Sister” and use the church’s address as the return address
If life gets in the wayTell the organizer, who quietly takes over for that sister
RevealA date on the calendar from the first day

The problem women’s ministry leaders mention most is the sister who gives and gets nothing back. A check-in at the halfway point and one or two quiet stand-ins solve most of it. Sign-up once a year also leaves newcomers out, so think about a second round.

Secret Sister gift ideas under $5 and $10

Around $5Around $10
Her favorite candy bar and a noteA small potted plant
Tea or cocoa packetsHand cream in her favorite scent
A pretty bookmarkA journal for prayer or notes
A packet of seedsA mug, if her form doesn’t say she has plenty
A pair of fun pensA small candle

Check the form first: allergies, and anything she asked you to avoid. These are ideas, not prices, and they change with the store.

Secret Sister card messages

MomentA message to copy
First cardI’m so glad I drew your name. I’ll be praying for you this year. Your Secret Sister
A hard weekYou came to mind today, so I stopped and prayed for you.
Her birthdayHappy birthday from someone who is thankful for you.
A funny oneI know your coffee order. I know your birthday. You still don’t know me.
Before the revealOnly a few weeks left. Have you figured me out yet?
RevealIt has been a joy to pray for you. Now you can put a face to the notes.

A short reveal poem, free to use: Each little note, each small surprise, / was love that wore a soft disguise. / The prayers were real, the friendship too: / your Secret Sister thanks God for you.

Bible verses for a Secret Sister card

ReferenceWhat it’s aboutGood for
Proverbs 17:17A friend loves at all timesThe first card
Philippians 1:3Giving thanks whenever you remember someoneAny time
Galatians 6:2Carrying each other’s burdensA hard week
1 Thessalonians 5:11Encouraging and building each other upA tired season
Psalm 46:1God as refuge and strengthBad news
Romans 15:13Being filled with joy and peaceA new start
Ecclesiastes 4:9–10Two are better than oneThe reveal

Secret Sister reveal ideas

IdeaHow it goes
Reveal brunchEveryone brings a dish, which keeps the cost down
Guessing gameRead a fact from each form aloud and let the room guess whose it is, then each sister stands
Last clueEach woman gets a final card saying where to sit, and her sister is in the next chair
Thank-you circleEach sister says one thing she prayed for, with permission, then gives a last small gift

A church Secret Sister and the Facebook chain

A church programThe Facebook chain
Who takes partPeople who already know each otherStrangers, friends of friends
What you’re askedPrayer, notes, small gifts you chooseMail a gift and recruit more people
What you’re promisedNothing in returnUp to 36 gifts
Your addressStays with the organizer, or isn’t neededGoes on a list that spreads
Is it legal?It’s a group of friends giving giftsThe BBB calls it an illegal pyramid scheme

FAQ

What is a Secret Sister program?

A church or women’s group matches its members in pairs, in secret. Each woman prays for her sister and sends cards or small gifts for a set time, from a few months to most of a year, and they find out who is who at a reveal lunch or party.

Is this the Facebook “Secret Sister” gift exchange?

No. That is a chain: you send a gift to a stranger, recruit six friends and are promised up to 36 gifts back. The Better Business Bureau calls it an illegal pyramid scheme and says the U.S. Postal Inspection Service treats these gift exchanges as a form of gambling. Don’t join one, and don’t give your address to it. A real program happens inside a group you already belong to.

What should a Secret Sister questionnaire ask?

Where gifts can be left, a birthday and any other date that matters, favorite colors, flowers, snacks and drinks, a favorite scent, hobbies, a favorite verse and hymn, what she would like prayer for, what to avoid, and allergies. Friends and coworkers get the same form with no faith questions.

How much should a Secret Sister spend?

What the group agrees on before anyone signs up. Some churches expect only prayer and notes, and small gifts are a bonus. Say the amount on the sign-up sheet so nobody feels outdone: type it in the Budget box and it prints at the top.

Why doesn’t the form ask for a home address?

A link can be forwarded, so an address shouldn’t travel in one. Cards can go through the church office, a mailbox or a gift table. If your group mails cards, keep the addresses on the organizer’s own list, or add the question to a paper form with “Your own questions”.

Related tools